My Experience Going to Church in North Korea - Jonathan Cheng
Read full transcript 10 segments
-
This is an obvious This is an obvious question, Jonathan, question, Jonathan, question, Jonathan, but you just mentioned but you just mentioned but you just mentioned that you've been to that you've been to that you've been to North Korea twice. What do North Korea twice. What do North Korea twice. What do we know we know we know about life inside about life inside about life inside North Korea today? Do North Korea today? Do North Korea today? Do we have any we have any we have any idea whether idea whether idea whether people are dissatisfied? Did you people are dissatisfied? Did you people are dissatisfied? Did you point out the different point out the different point out the different views on the views on the views on the sustainability of the church? You sustainability of the church? You sustainability of the church? You left some left some left some ambiguity because I'm ambiguity because I'm ambiguity because I'm sure we sure we sure we simply can't simply can't simply can't know. Are there know. Are there know. Are there any signs of any signs of any signs of weakness in the weakness in the weakness in the Kim dynasty? I'm sure Kim dynasty? I'm sure Kim dynasty? I'm sure you get asked these you get asked these you get asked these questions often. questions often. questions often. Yes, that's true, and I Yes, that's true, and I Yes, that's true, and I think about it myself. think about it myself. think about it myself. I would like to give them I would like to give them I would like to give them answers. And of course, answers. And of course, answers. And of course, I don't think anyone I don't think anyone I don't think anyone really knows. really knows. really knows. That is, what is That is, what is That is, what is everyday life like everyday life like everyday life like if we know that there are if we know that there are if we know that there are North Koreans North Koreans North Koreans fleeing the country. This fleeing the country. This fleeing the country. This happens much less happens much less happens much less often, as often, as often, as technology, in my technology, in my technology, in my opinion, has given the state opinion, has given the state opinion, has given the state even more even more even more advantages than it has given advantages than it has given advantages than it has given citizens. So this made it citizens. So this made it citizens. So this made it much more difficult to much more difficult to much more difficult to escape the country. But escape the country. But escape the country. But more than 30,000 more than 30,000 more than 30,000 North Koreans North Koreans North Koreans have fled the country, have fled the country, have fled the country, almost all before COVID, and almost all before COVID, and almost all before COVID, and have reached South have reached South have reached South Korea or other countries, Korea or other countries, Korea or other countries, including the United States, Canada, including the United States, Canada, including the United States, Canada, and several others. So and several others. So and several others. So we have their we have their we have their testimonies. We know what testimonies. We know what testimonies. We know what their lives were like.
-
their lives were like. their lives were like. Things are changing, and Things are changing, and Things are changing, and under Kim Jong-un, in the under Kim Jong-un, in the under Kim Jong-un, in the last few years, there have last few years, there have last few years, there have been far been far been far fewer escapes. There is a question as to fewer escapes. There is a question as to fewer escapes. There is a question as to whether whether any part of the church remains in North Korea. any part of the church remains in North Korea. I think most I think most I think most would agree that it is. would agree that it is. would agree that it is. But how But how But how big is it? How big is it? How big is it? How many people are we many people are we many people are we talking about? I don't think talking about? I don't think talking about? I don't think anyone can give a definitive anyone can give a definitive anyone can give a definitive answer, perhaps not answer, perhaps not answer, perhaps not even the members of even the members of even the members of this church themselves this church themselves this church themselves inside North inside North inside North Korea. I don't think Korea. I don't think Korea. I don't think they know they know they know how many there are. In addition to the how many there are. In addition to the how many there are. In addition to the underground church, underground church, underground church, there is also the legal one, because there is also the legal one, because there is also the legal one, because Kim Il Sung was Kim Il Sung was Kim Il Sung was dying, and he died in dying, and he died in dying, and he died in 1994... He 1994... He 1994... He eventually comes to an eventually comes to an eventually comes to an extraordinary extraordinary extraordinary return to faith, return to faith, return to faith, which I mentioned which I mentioned which I mentioned earlier, right? So earlier, right? So earlier, right? So he invites he invites he invites Billy Graham Billy Graham Billy Graham to visit him twice. He to visit him twice. He to visit him twice. He invites Jimmy invites Jimmy invites Jimmy Carter to visit Carter to visit Carter to visit him. But he also him. But he also him. But he also invites a number of invites a number of invites a number of Korean- Korean- American American American pastors to visit pastors to visit pastors to visit him in Pyongyang. With him in Pyongyang. With him in Pyongyang. With some of them, he some of them, he some of them, he says a prayer says a prayer says a prayer before eating. before eating. before eating. He impresses some of them with his He impresses some of them with his He impresses some of them with his knowledge of the Bible. knowledge of the Bible. After all, he built After all, he built two Protestant two Protestant two Protestant churches in Pyongyang churches in Pyongyang churches in Pyongyang that still stand today, where that still stand today, where that still stand today, where Billy Graham spoke Billy Graham spoke Billy Graham spoke during both of his during both of his during both of his visits and which I was able to visits and which I was able to visits and which I was able to visit in 2017.
-
visit in 2017. So, uh, when I So, uh, when I went there in 2017, went there in 2017, went there in 2017, I was there as a reporter for the I was there as a reporter for the I was there as a reporter for the Wall Street Journal. They Wall Street Journal. They Wall Street Journal. They specifically invited the specifically invited the specifically invited the Wall Street Journal to send Wall Street Journal to send Wall Street Journal to send reporters on reporters on reporters on the trip to the trip to the trip to cover the events. There cover the events. There cover the events. There were only four of us were only four of us . There were four of us . There were four of us . There were four of us from the Wall Street Journal. We all from the Wall Street Journal. We all from the Wall Street Journal. We all arrived together. And uh arrived together. And uh , on the first night at , on the first night at , on the first night at dinner, our dinner, our dinner, our curators from curators from curators from the Ministry of the Ministry of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs Foreign Affairs Foreign Affairs asked us, "What would you asked us, "What would you asked us, "What would you like to see here? like to see here? like to see here? What would you like What would you like What would you like to report on?" It to report on?" It to report on?" It was 2017, during was 2017, during Trump's first term. This was the peak of the Trump's first term. This was the peak of the nuclear nuclear nuclear standoff between standoff between standoff between Donald Trump and Donald Trump and Donald Trump and Kim Jong-un. And Kim Jong-un. And Kim Jong-un. And the reason they the reason they the reason they invited us invited us invited us to come to to come to to come to North Korea, I North Korea, I North Korea, I think, was think, was think, was because they wanted to because they wanted to because they wanted to show us the strength of the show us the strength of the show us the strength of the country. And they wanted country. And they wanted country. And they wanted to show us that they were not to show us that they were not to show us that they were not going to going to going to back down to back down to back down to US pressure. But once US pressure. But once US pressure. But once we were there, they did we were there, they did we were there, they did n't have much of a n't have much of a n't have much of a plan for us. They plan for us. They plan for us. They wanted to show us wanted to show us wanted to show us that their economy was that their economy was doing well under doing well under sanctions. They sanctions. They sanctions. They wanted to show us both wanted to show us both wanted to show us both . So as . So as . So as reporters, we reporters, we reporters, we asked for the asked for the asked for the most obvious thing: we most obvious thing: we most obvious thing: we asked for an asked for an asked for an interview with Kim Jong- interview with Kim Jong- interview with Kim Jong- un. And uh, they un. And uh, they un. And uh, they politely declined.
-
politely declined. politely declined. We asked for a We asked for a We asked for a visit to the nuclear visit to the nuclear visit to the nuclear facilities, which was facilities, which was facilities, which was also politely also politely also politely denied. Um, but denied. Um, but denied. Um, but besides that, we besides that, we besides that, we asked for a lot more asked for a lot more asked for a lot more . . . Can we see this Can we see this ? Can we ? Can we ? Can we see that? Can see that? Can see that? Can we go, uh, we go, uh, we go, uh, can we visit can we visit can we visit the hospital? Can we the hospital? Can we the hospital? Can we go here and there? And go here and there? And go here and there? And at some point it at some point it at some point it dawned on me, and I just dawned on me, and I just dawned on me, and I just said, you know, I was said, you know, I was said, you know, I was already working already working already working on this book at that time. I on this book at that time. I on this book at that time. I told them: I know told them: I know told them: I know you have you have you have two Protestant two Protestant two Protestant churches here in Pyongyang. It just so happens churches here in Pyongyang. It just so happens churches here in Pyongyang. It just so happens that we are here on the weekend. that we are here on the weekend. that we are here on the weekend. Is it possible for us Is it possible for us Is it possible for us to go to church on to go to church on to go to church on Sunday morning? And they Sunday morning? And they Sunday morning? And they said, "Oh, that's an said, "Oh, that's an said, "Oh, that's an interesting request." I don't interesting request." I don't interesting request." I don't think they think they think they expected me to expected me to expected me to ask that. But they ask that. But they ask that. But they said, "We'll said, "We'll said, "We'll look into it." And look into it." And look into it." And indeed, on Sunday indeed, on Sunday indeed, on Sunday morning they brought morning they brought morning they brought us to two us to two us to two Protestant Protestant Protestant churches that Kim Il Sung churches that Kim Il Sung churches that Kim Il Sung had built in the capital. And had built in the capital. And had built in the capital. And I don't want to say whether I don't want to say whether I don't want to say whether these churches are real these churches are real these churches are real or fake or whatever or fake or whatever or fake or whatever you want to call them. Um, I you want to call them. Um, I you want to call them. Um, I can only say can only say can only say one thing. At the church one thing. At the church one thing. At the church service we service we service we attended, there attended, there attended, there were no pictures of Kim Il were no pictures of Kim Il were no pictures of Kim Il Sung on the walls. The people Sung on the walls. The people Sung on the walls. The people inside did not have inside did not have inside did not have Kim Il- Kim Il- Kim Il- sung badges pinned to their sung badges pinned to their sung badges pinned to their hearts or lapels.
-
hearts or lapels. hearts or lapels. Um, there were Bibles on the benches Um, there were Bibles on the benches Um, there were Bibles on the benches . Inside, it . Inside, it . Inside, it looked like a church. looked like a church. looked like a church. I mean, I I mean, I I mean, I lived in South lived in South lived in South Korea for six years. It Korea for six years. It Korea for six years. It looked like the interior of a looked like the interior of a looked like the interior of a South Korean South Korean South Korean church. Um, there were church. Um, there were church. Um, there were wooden benches, and on wooden benches, and on wooden benches, and on the backs of the benches were the backs of the benches were Bibles in Korean Bibles in Korean Bibles in Korean . It contains all 66 . It contains all 66 . It contains all 66 books of the Bible. Um, you books of the Bible. Um, you books of the Bible. Um, you can flip through them. can flip through them. can flip through them. They have a collection of hymns. They have a collection of hymns. They have a collection of hymns. All of this was donated by All of this was donated by All of this was donated by South Korean South Korean South Korean Christians. So, these are, Christians. So, these are, Christians. So, these are, so to speak, so to speak, so to speak, real Bibles. Um, real Bibles. Um, real Bibles. Um, when a pastor goes out when a pastor goes out when a pastor goes out to the pulpit to to the pulpit to to the pulpit to preach, he doesn't preach, he doesn't preach, he doesn't preach preach preach Kimirsenism. He does not Kimirsenism. He does not Kimirsenism. He does not preach this or that preach this or that . He preached from a . He preached from a . He preached from a passage from the Bible. passage from the Bible. passage from the Bible. I actually don't I actually don't I actually don't remember what exactly the remember what exactly the remember what exactly the passage was. It's been passage was. It's been passage was. It's been almost ten almost ten almost ten years, but it seems like years, but it seems like years, but it seems like it was from the Gospel. it was from the Gospel. it was from the Gospel. I think he I think he I think he preached from preached from preached from one of the four one of the four one of the four Gospels. Um, and it Gospels. Um, and it Gospels. Um, and it was a relatively was a relatively was a relatively innocent message. innocent message. innocent message. It didn't require It didn't require It didn't require selling all your selling all your selling all your possessions or giving your possessions or giving your possessions or giving your life to Christ or anything life to Christ or anything life to Christ or anything like that, it was kind of like that, it was kind of like that, it was kind of , you know, , you know, , you know, one of the more one of the more one of the more enjoyable stories from the enjoyable stories from the enjoyable stories from the Gospel that was chosen Gospel that was chosen Gospel that was chosen to preach. And to preach. And to preach. And the gist was something the gist was something the gist was something like: well, I don't know, like: well, I don't know, like: well, I don't know, work hard, work hard, work hard, love your family or love your family or love your family or something like that, right something like that, right ? So, that was the ? So, that was the ? So, that was the message. And so, message. And so, you know, I don't want to you know, I don't want to say that this say that this say that this means there is means there is means there is religious freedom in religious freedom in religious freedom in North Korea, because there is absolutely none in North Korea, because there is absolutely none in North Korea, because there is absolutely none in North Korea North Korea North Korea . And . And . And yet, I think what's yet, I think what's yet, I think what's happening here is that happening here is that happening here is that Kim Il Sung was never Kim Il Sung was never Kim Il Sung was never able to completely able to completely able to completely break away from break away from break away from his church his church his church upbringing. I believe upbringing. I believe upbringing. I believe he had a deep he had a deep he had a deep debt to faith, and debt to faith, and debt to faith, and felt that this also had
-
felt that this also had felt that this also had a lot a lot a lot to do with his to do with his to do with his mother, as mother, as mother, as she was a "biblical she was a "biblical she was a "biblical woman." This was her woman." This was her woman." This was her position in the church. This position in the church. This position in the church. This was a role that the was a role that the was a role that the Presbyterian Presbyterian Presbyterian Church created 100 Church created 100 Church created 100 years ago, since years ago, since years ago, since women could not be women could not be women could not be ordained or ordained or ordained or appointed to appointed to appointed to leadership positions, but leadership positions, but leadership positions, but they could take on the they could take on the they could take on the role of "Bible role of "Bible role of "Bible Woman" and actually Woman" and actually Woman" and actually be a female be a female evangelist, evangelist, evangelist, sharing the Gospel sharing the Gospel sharing the Gospel and teaching women to read and teaching women to read and teaching women to read using using using the Bible. And so she, the Bible. And so she, you know, in you know, in Kim Il Sung's mind, I don't Kim Il Sung's mind, I don't Kim Il Sung's mind, I don't think you can think you can think you can separate the church separate the church separate the church from his mother or from his mother or from his mother or his mother from the church his mother from the church , because for him they , because for him they , because for him they were inextricably were inextricably were inextricably linked. And there is such a linked. And there is such a linked. And there is such a wonderful moment. Yes. wonderful moment. Yes. wonderful moment. Yes. This is one of those This is one of those This is one of those "aha" moments that are "aha" moments that are "aha" moments that are in North Korean in North Korean in North Korean sources, and it's a fairly sources, and it's a fairly sources, and it's a fairly little-known moment. little-known moment. Um, I don't know Um, I don't know if anyone ever knew if anyone ever knew if anyone ever knew about this before, as such about this before, as such , but it was a meeting between , but it was a meeting between , but it was a meeting between Kim Il Sung and one of Kim Il Sung and one of Kim Il Sung and one of his, um, his, um, his, um, high-ranking high-ranking high-ranking deputies, and they were deputies, and they were deputies, and they were talking, and it's talking, and it's talking, and it's recorded for us in the recorded for us in the recorded for us in the official official official North Korean North Korean North Korean transcript, where he kind of transcript, where he kind of transcript, where he kind of says, "I had a dream about my mother says, "I had a dream about my mother , and I don't know what it , and I don't know what it means." And keep in means." And keep in means." And keep in mind, Kim Il Sung has been here mind, Kim Il Sung has been here mind, Kim Il Sung has been here for 70 or 80 years.
-
for 70 or 80 years. for 70 or 80 years. He has been He has been He has been leading leading leading this incredible this incredible this incredible cult of personality for several decades. Um, but cult of personality for several decades. Um, but cult of personality for several decades. Um, but his mother comes to his mother comes to his mother comes to him in a dream, and he him in a dream, and he him in a dream, and he doesn't explain the context of doesn't explain the context of doesn't explain the context of the dream, what's happening the dream, what's happening the dream, what's happening in the dream, what his mother is saying, in the dream, what his mother is saying, in the dream, what his mother is saying, but he asks his but he asks his but he asks his interlocutor, "What should interlocutor, "What should interlocutor, "What should I do?" He is I do?" He is I do?" He is clearly upset by this clearly upset by this clearly upset by this dream because he doesn't know dream because he doesn't know dream because he doesn't know how to take it. And how to take it. And how to take it. And here is the answer, and here is the answer, and here is the answer, and the person he the person he the person he is talking to is not a is talking to is not a is talking to is not a Christian, but Christian, but Christian, but he says, "You should he says, "You should he says, "You should build a church on the build a church on the build a church on the place where place where place where your mother was born." which is a your mother was born." which is a your mother was born." which is a pretty interesting, um, pretty interesting, um, pretty interesting, um, answer here. And, answer here. And, answer here. And, of course, that's exactly what Kim Il of course, that's exactly what Kim Il of course, that's exactly what Kim Il Sung then does. Sung then does. Sung then does. He goes and, um, looks for the He goes and, um, looks for the He goes and, um, looks for the specific place where specific place where specific place where his mother was born, his mother was born, his mother was born, identifies it, and identifies it, and identifies it, and orders a church to be built orders a church to be built orders a church to be built there. And again there. And again there. And again , this is the church that , this is the church that Billy Graham later spoke at and that I Billy Graham later spoke at and that I also attended. And also attended. And also attended. And so, um, you know, I don't so, um, you know, I don't so, um, you know, I don't want to speak for Kim want to speak for Kim want to speak for Kim Il Sung. Um, I don't know Il Sung. Um, I don't know Il Sung. Um, I don't know what's going on in what's going on in what's going on in his heart. Um, I don't his heart. Um, I don't his heart. Um, I don't know if he was know if he was ever a Christian. ever a Christian. ever a Christian. I don't know if he was I don't know if he was I don't know if he was ever a believer. Um, ever a believer. Um, ever a believer. Um, people ask me this people ask me this people ask me this quite often.
-
quite often. quite often. They say, "Was They say, "Was They say, "Was Kim Il Sung a Kim Il Sung a Kim Il Sung a Christian?" And Christian?" And Christian?" And you know, I mean you know, I mean , listen, everyone has their own , listen, everyone has their own , listen, everyone has their own definition of what it definition of what it definition of what it means to be a means to be a means to be a Christian. Um, I would Christian. Um, I would Christian. Um, I would definitely say he definitely say he definitely say he was a cultural was a cultural was a cultural Christian. He Christian. He Christian. He certainly grew up in certainly grew up in certainly grew up in church, but to me church, but to me church, but to me that's not the same as being a that's not the same as being a that's not the same as being a Christian. I don't Christian. I don't Christian. I don't know if he had a know if he had a know if he had a personal relationship with personal relationship with personal relationship with Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ. Let's say this. I Let's say this. I Let's say this. I mean, I don't know, um, mean, I don't know, um, mean, I don't know, um, because I'm not him. I didn't because I'm not him. I didn't because I'm not him. I didn't talk to him. He talk to him. He talk to him. He died in 1994. And, died in 1994. And, died in 1994. And, ultimately, what he ultimately, what he ultimately, what he truly believed deep down truly believed deep down truly believed deep down was something was something was something that, frankly, on that, frankly, on that, frankly, on some level, was a some level, was a some level, was a matter between him matter between him matter between him and God. Isn't that right? It's and God. Isn't that right? It's and God. Isn't that right? It's not for me to judge and it's not for not for me to judge and it's not for not for me to judge and it's not for you. I just don't think you. I just don't think we know. I think, we know. I think, we know. I think, however, we can however, we can however, we can say that he say that he say that he was certainly a was certainly a was certainly a cultural cultural cultural Christian and Christian and Christian and carried that legacy carried that legacy carried that legacy throughout his life. throughout his life. That formed a big That formed a big part of what he part of what he part of what he did for did for did for decades as decades as decades as the ruler of these 25 the ruler of these 25 the ruler of these 25 million people in million people in million people in North Korea, and North Korea, and North Korea, and his legacy lives on his legacy lives on his legacy lives on even after his even after his even after his death, because, first of all, death, because, first of all, death, because, first of all, he remains the " he remains the " eternal president" of eternal president" of eternal president" of North Korea, as it's North Korea, as it's North Korea, as it's written in written in written in the constitution, and the constitution, and second of all, they second of all, they second of all, they put up all these put up all these put up all these obelisks, like the obelisks, like the obelisks, like the Washington Monument Washington Monument , these big, pointy , these big, pointy , these big, pointy structures everywhere. I structures everywhere. I structures everywhere. I saw them. Um, there's one saw them. Um, there's one saw them. Um, there's one even here in Beijing, even here in Beijing, even here in Beijing, near the near the near the North Korean embassy. Um, North Korean embassy. Um, North Korean embassy. Um, but they're all over the but they're all over the but they're all over the country, tens of thousands country, tens of thousands country, tens of thousands of them. And they all have the same thing of them. And they all have the same thing of them. And they all have the same thing written on the side written on the side written on the side . They say: . They say: . They say: "Our leader, our "Our leader, our "Our leader, our great leader, great leader, great leader, Comrade Kim Il Sung, Comrade Kim Il Sung, Comrade Kim Il Sung, will be with us forever." And will be with us forever." And will be with us forever." And they are called the towers
-
they are called the towers they are called the towers of immortality. And of immortality. And of immortality. And actually, you know, it was actually, you know, it was actually, you know, it was first pointed out by first pointed out by first pointed out by a missionary, because American missionaries were operating in a missionary, because American missionaries were operating in a missionary, because American missionaries were operating in North Korea North Korea , at least , at least before Covid. And this was before Covid. And this was before Covid. And this was one of them, a man one of them, a man one of them, a man from North from North from North Carolina. I won't Carolina. I won't Carolina. I won't go into details. go into details. go into details. But he tells me that the But he tells me that the But he tells me that the language here is very similar language here is very similar language here is very similar to the language we see to the language we see to the language we see around Christ at the around Christ at the around Christ at the ascension. When ascension. When ascension. When he rises and he rises and he rises and says, "I am leaving you, says, "I am leaving you, says, "I am leaving you, but I will leave the but I will leave the but I will leave the Holy Spirit with you." "I Holy Spirit with you." "I Holy Spirit with you." "I will be with you." " will be with you." " Present with you." And Present with you." And Present with you." And so it lives on after so it lives on after so it lives on after death and passes on death and passes on death and passes on to the third to the third to the third generation, and now generation, and now generation, and now perhaps the perhaps the perhaps the fourth, as fourth, as fourth, as we see we see we see North Korea North Korea North Korea potentially preparing potentially preparing potentially preparing for a transfer of power to the for a transfer of power to the for a transfer of power to the fourth generation fourth generation . And I don't think I need to . And I don't think I need to . And I don't think I need to remind everyone that remind everyone that remind everyone that this is a nuclear- this is a nuclear- this is a nuclear- armed state. And so this is a armed state. And so this is a armed state. And so this is a state that, state that, state that, as far as we know, as far as we know, as far as we know, could last for could last for could last for decades. I'm not decades. I'm not decades. I'm not saying I want this to saying I want this to saying I want this to happen, but it's a happen, but it's a happen, but it's a geopolitical geopolitical geopolitical problem that has problem that has problem that has puzzled every puzzled every puzzled every administration administration administration since Truman, since Truman, since Truman, and no one has been able and no one has been able and no one has been able to figure out what to do about to figure out what to do about to figure out what to do about North Korea. But North Korea. But North Korea. But in a way, in a way, in a way, geopolitically, they've geopolitically, they've geopolitically, they've only gotten only gotten only gotten stronger and stronger and stronger and stronger over the stronger over the stronger over the years in terms of their years in terms of their years in terms of their military and military and military and nuclear assets. So nuclear assets. So , um, yeah, this world , um, yeah, this world , um, yeah, this world that they've created in that they've created in that they've created in North Korea, this, North Korea, this, North Korea, this, this alternate this alternate this alternate reality where the reality where the reality where the Kims are considered Kims are considered Kims are considered living deities— living deities— they've essentially they've essentially they've essentially replaced Christ, the replaced Christ, the replaced Christ, the Christian God, with the
-
Christian God, with the Christian God, with the Kim family. Hmm, it Kim family. Hmm, it Kim family. Hmm, it could last for could last for could last for many, many more years. many, many more years. many, many more years. And I say this not because I And I say this not because I And I say this not because I hope so, but hope so, but hope so, but because that is the world because that is the world because that is the world we live in.
Summary
The transcript explores the realities of life inside North Korea, focusing on the challenges of defector testimonies, the impact of modern state technology on escapes, and the ambiguous status of the underground and legal church. It references figures such as the Kim dynasty, Billy Graham, and Jimmy Carter, alongside historical visits to Pyongyang. The practical takeaway is that while definitive knowledge about everyday life and the exact size of the church remains elusive due to strict government control, insights are gathered through the testimonies of defectors and historical accounts of religious interactions in the region.